Visually, acrylic and gel nail extensions may appear similar, but they have distinct characteristics that set them apart. Nail professionals often debate which product is superior or preferable, but the answer isn’t straightforward. Industry trends also play a role—acrylic, for example, is experiencing a resurgence after years of gel’s dominance. The debate remains lively, and walking into any salon could spark a spirited discussion. Let’s dive into the difference between gel nail extensions and acrylic, and which option may be best for you!
Differences Between Acrylic and Gel: Properties
Acrylic is incredibly versatile. It air-dries, unlike gel, which requires UV light for curing. Acrylic is made by mixing a monomer (liquid) and polymer (powder) to create a moldable, clay-like material. Sculpting gel, by contrast, comes pre-mixed with its monomer and polymer, emits little odor, and cures quickly under a UV light.
Acrylic is porous, meaning gel or gel polish can adhere to its surface. However, gel is non- porous so the reverse isn't possible, only gel or gel polish will adhere to gel. Acrylic is generally easier for building length, but a skilled technician can achieve similar results with gel.
Differences Between Acrylic and Gel: Removal
Acrylic can be removed by soaking it in acetone, a simple and inexpensive process. Gel, on the other hand, needs to be filed off, often requiring an electric file for efficiency. Although acrylic can technically be soaked off, many professionals still rely on filing for removal. This distinction can be useful for at-home enthusiasts or in specific situations.
When to Get Acrylic vs Gel
The choice between acrylic and gel often depends on the client’s needs and preferences. For example, acrylic is ideal for nail-biters because it’s thicker and more durable. Its ease of length-building is also beneficial for clients with severely bitten nails. Over time, acrylic can even help correct misshapen growth channels.
On the other hand, clients who want intricate nail art with significant dimension will benefit more from gel’s sculpting properties. Ultimately, the “right” choice depends on the specific circumstances. For example, gel might be a better option for clients who have their hands in water (ex. hairdressers, bartenders, etc) since gel is non-porous.
What’s the Right Choice for Beginners?
Experts at Young Nails recommend starting with gel if beginners want to focus on one skill initially. Gel is versatile, with applications ranging from builder gels to paints. This allows new technicians to offer a variety of services early on, boosting their value to salons. Additionally, mastering gel helps develop the muscle control needed to transition to acrylic later.